The owner was very kind, welcoming and honest. I had a lot of coins and some notes I had no idea of their value and he pulled out the “blue book value” and gave me an honest price. Much appreciated, would definitely do business with them again.
Date of Posting: 05 April 2018
Posted By: Daniel
We really didn't know what to expect when we brought along silver bars, silver coins and estate jewelry. Mike was extremely knowledgeable, thorough and fair in his assessments. There's a sense of honesty and integrity in dealing with him. Highly recommended.
Date of Posting: 19 May 2017
Posted By: Lola
I can't say enough good things about this company. Fast. Fair. Fantastic. I will definitely recommend it to my friends and family. They were such a pleasure to deal with.
Date of Posting: 18 May 2017
Posted By: Tim
I had the privilege of liquidating some silver coins with your company. The coins were part of my uncle's collection, and I knew nothing about them, except that they should probably not be spent at the laundromat! Mike, the president, took the time to explain the origin of the coins, as well as their worth. I got a sense of his true passion for the coin business, as well as his utter trustworthiness and professionalism.
I recommend Carsleys without hesitation. They will treat you with respect and fairness. What more could anyone ask?
Date of Posting: 08 May 2017
Posted By: Rachel Abugov
I brought a batch of coins to Carsley Whetstone today, unsure of how events would unfold. Mike greeted me pleasantly, despite my being 20 minutes early for our meeting. I had Googled "Montreal coin dealers", read several positive reviews of Carsley Whetstone, and so decided to give them a try. I must say that I was favorably impressed with the fairness of the evaluation. I had done a little bit of research on coin values, and I was sure that I had a good deal when Mike tallied the final figure. I would recommend Carsley Whetstone to anyone thinking of selling their coins or any other valuables, even if just for an evaluation. These folks are recognised experts, and are often involved in evaluating estates. After the fair treatment I received, I would not hesitate to return.
Date of Posting: 28 February 2014
Posted By: James McDonnell
Very pleasant contact- extremely knowlegeable, courteous and patient.
Will no doubt refer/deal with him once again in the future.
Date of Posting: 17 January 2014
Posted By: J LeB
We have had a multi facet business arrangement with Carsley Whetstone & Co. over the past 16 years. We acknowledge that they are the experts - "your go to people for coins and precious metals". I have had the privilege of working both with previous owner William Whetstone and in recent years Mike Joffre. Both gentlemen have assisted me with the upmost intregrity, and I always felt that I was treated fairly. They have always shared their knowledge freely, to help us service our clients better. I would not hesitate to refer my family, friends, and clients to this firm.
Date of Posting: 12 September 2013
Posted By: Theresa E. Taylor & Associates Auctioneering
Dealing with Carsley Whetstone is first class. Mike (the President, and head buyer) is honest, and fair. I have had many transactions with them and never have been less than 100% satisfied.
Date of Posting: 10 July 2013
Posted By: Darryl Lesser
<< Start Previous 1 Next Last >>
Page 1 of 1
Submit A Testimonial